Patrimonial responsibility of the Administration. Sanitary responsibility
Commentary on the Tribunal Supremo of 2 january 2012
Keywords:
resource of cassation, patrimonial responsibility, valuation of the judicial test, infraction of «lex artis»Abstract
In this judgment the Supreme Court comes to revoke a previous failure of the Top Court of Justice of Madrid, recognizing the patrimonial responsibility which the Service Of Madrid of Health incurred on the occasion of a childbirth gemelar in that due to the lack of diligence of the physicians, there were caused to one of the babies a series of injuries that derived in a cerebral chronic paralysis. After the joint analysis of all the medical judgments that were realized, the Supreme Court thinks that a loss existed of «lex artis» since «on not having given to the parents of the girl the right to have a clinical complete and rigorous history with the suffering of the happened in the childbirth, has prevented them from accrediting if really it took place or not foetal suffering of the fetus», for what «it is the Administration who must have facilitated this documentation must run with the prejudices of the lack of test on which certainly it was not the foetal suffering what caused the hipoxia of the fetus, and it has not done it either». In addition, it exposes that «a hypothesis one has forbidden him of capacity to prove and defend respect that the administration was in better position». Because of it, it recognizes the appellant an indemnification «for loss of "lex artis"».









